# Central St. (OH) (0-4,0-0 SIAC) -VS- # Rockhurst (3-4,0-0 GLVC)

Box Score

Central St. (OH) logo
0
vs
Rockhurst logo
3

# Central St. (OH) (0-4,0-0 SIAC)
-VS-
# Rockhurst (3-4,0-0 GLVC)

Team Score By Period
Team 1 2 3
Central St. (OH) CentSt 20 18 23
Winner Rockhurst Rock 25 25 25
Date:
1/24/2026
Time:
6:54 pm
Site:
Kansas City, MO (Mason-Halpin Field House)
Attendance:
75
VIEW
Match History vs Rockhurst

Match Details

Game Statistics By Set
Set Central St. (OH) Rockhurst
K E TA % K E TA %
Set #1 8 10 26 -0.077 7 4 18 0.167
Set #2 8 5 24 0.125 11 4 24 0.292
Set #3 16 6 36 0.278 15 6 33 0.273
Total 32 21 86 .128 33 14 75 .253
Team Statistical Comparison
Statistic Team Comparison
CentSt - Rock
Points
41.0
43.5
Kills
32
33
Aces
3
4
Blocks
6
6
Assists
31
31
Digs
25
31

Game Leaders

CentSt - Leaders
Statistic Leaders
Kills Harris, Jaedyn (8), Falayi, Simon (7), Williams IV, Toulmin (7)
Aces Patrick, Bradley (2), Harris, Jaedyn (1)
Blocks Falayi, Simon (3), Patrick, Bradley (2), Trimuel, Prince (2)
Assists Patrick, Bradley (27), Latham, Benjamin (3), Smith, Preston (1)
Digs Latham, Benjamin (7), Williams IV, Toulmin (5), Patrick, Bradley (5)
Rock - Leaders
Statistic Leaders
Kills Huhman, Quentin (10), Spadaro, Shay (7), Massey, Trent (5)
Aces Yusk, Wesley (1), DeRoy, Aron (1), Tran, Lucas (1)
Blocks DeRoy, Aron (5), Jacques, Nathan (2), Yusk, Wesley (1)
Assists Jacques, Nathan (25), Spadaro, Shay (2), DeRoy, Aron (2)
Digs Collins, Ryan (5), Spadaro, Shay (5), Huhman, Quentin (5)

Individual Statistics

Central St. (OH) (0-4,0-0 SIAC)

CentSt - Individual
# Player SP Attack Set Serve Block Def Rec
K E TA Pct A E SA SE SA-SE BS BA BE DIG BHE RE Pts
5 5 Falayi, Simon 3 7 4 13 .231 0 0 0 3 0-3 0 3 0 1 0 0 8.5
7 7 Williams IV, Toulmin 3 7 5 21 .095 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 5 0 1 7.0
3 3 Harris, Jaedyn 3 8 5 21 .143 0 0 1 4 1-4 0 1 0 3 0 0 9.5
2 2 Latham, Benjamin 3 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 7 0 0 0.0
11 11 Patrick, Bradley 3 0 1 5 -.200 27 2 2 2 2-2 1 1 0 5 0 0 3.5
22 22 Smith, Preston 3 3 4 14 -.071 1 0 0 1 0-1 0 1 0 3 0 1 3.5
18 18 Trimuel, Prince 3 6 1 8 .625 0 0 0 3 0-3 1 1 0 1 0 0 7.5
19 19 Durrah, Jayden 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
10 10 Symes, Deegan 1 1 1 4 .000 0 0 0 2 0-2 0 1 0 0 0 0 1.5
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0
Totals 32 21 86 .128 31 2 3 15 3-15 2 8 0 25 0 4 41
CentSt - Individual
# Player SP Block Def Rec Pts
BS BA BE DIG BHE RE
5 5 Falayi, Simon 3 0 3 0 1 0 0 8.5
7 7 Williams IV, Toulmin 3 0 0 0 5 0 1 7.0
3 3 Harris, Jaedyn 3 0 1 0 3 0 0 9.5
2 2 Latham, Benjamin 3 0 0 0 7 0 0 0.0
11 11 Patrick, Bradley 3 1 1 0 5 0 0 3.5
22 22 Smith, Preston 3 0 1 0 3 0 1 3.5
18 18 Trimuel, Prince 3 1 1 0 1 0 0 7.5
19 19 Durrah, Jayden 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
10 10 Symes, Deegan 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1.5
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0
Totals 2 8 0 25 0 4 41

Rockhurst (3-4,0-0 GLVC)

Rock - Individual
# Player SP Attack Set Serve Block Def Rec
K E TA Pct A E SA SE SA-SE BS BA BE DIG BHE RE Pts
3 3 Jacques, Nathan 3 2 1 4 .250 25 1 0 1 0-1 0 2 0 4 0 0 3.0
7 7 Spadaro, Shay 3 7 8 20 -.050 2 0 0 4 0-4 0 0 0 5 0 0 7.0
11 11 DeRoy, Aron 3 3 1 7 .286 2 0 1 1 1-1 3 2 0 3 0 0 8.0
15 15 Huhman, Quentin 3 10 2 21 .381 2 0 1 2 1-2 0 1 0 5 0 0 11.5
17 17 Collins, Ryan 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 5 0 1 0.0
10 10 Yusk, Wesley 2 3 0 6 .500 0 0 1 0 1-0 0 1 0 0 0 0 4.5
24 24 Tran, Lucas 2 2 1 8 .125 0 0 1 2 1-2 0 1 0 1 0 1 3.5
1 1 Massey, Trent 2 5 1 6 .667 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 3 0 0 5.0
8 8 Sutphen, Will 1 1 0 3 .333 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 2 0 0 1.0
12 12 McCue, Bailey 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
16 16 Daugherty, Jackson 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0.0
4 4 Soto, Enrique 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0-1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0
Totals 33 14 75 .253 31 1 4 11 4-11 3 7 0 31 0 3 43.5
Rock - Individual
# Player SP Block Def Rec Pts
BS BA BE DIG BHE RE
3 3 Jacques, Nathan 3 0 2 0 4 0 0 3.0
7 7 Spadaro, Shay 3 0 0 0 5 0 0 7.0
11 11 DeRoy, Aron 3 3 2 0 3 0 0 8.0
15 15 Huhman, Quentin 3 0 1 0 5 0 0 11.5
17 17 Collins, Ryan 2 0 0 0 5 0 1 0.0
10 10 Yusk, Wesley 2 0 1 0 0 0 0 4.5
24 24 Tran, Lucas 2 0 1 0 1 0 1 3.5
1 1 Massey, Trent 2 0 0 0 3 0 0 5.0
8 8 Sutphen, Will 1 0 0 0 2 0 0 1.0
12 12 McCue, Bailey 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
16 16 Daugherty, Jackson 1 0 0 0 3 0 0 0.0
4 4 Soto, Enrique 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0
Totals 3 7 0 31 0 3 43.5

Play By Play

Set #1 Plays

Set #1 Plays
Serve Team CentSt - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score Rock - Play Description
Rock [DeRoy, Aron] Kill by Trimuel, Prince Michael (from Patrick, Bradley). 1 Rockhurst 0
CentSt [Patrick, Bradley] Kill by Trimuel, Prince Michael (from Smith, Preston). 2 Rockhurst 0
CentSt [Patrick, Bradley] Service ace (Team). 3 Rockhurst 0
CentSt [Patrick, Bradley] Attack error by Spadaro, Shay (block by Harris, Jaedyn; Trimuel, Prince Michael). 4 Rockhurst 0
CentSt [Patrick, Bradley] Service ace (Tran, Lucas). 5 Rockhurst 0
CentSt 5 Central St. (OH) 1 [Patrick, Bradley] Kill by Jacques, Nathan (from Huhman, Quentin).
Rock [Jacques, Nathan] Kill by Harris, Jaedyn (from Patrick, Bradley). 6 Rockhurst 1
CentSt [Harris, Jaedyn] Attack error by Spadaro, Shay (from Jacques, Nathan). 7 Rockhurst 1
CentSt 7 Central St. (OH) 2 [Harris, Jaedyn] Service error.
Rock 7 Central St. (OH) 3 [Spadaro, Shay] Attack error by Harris, Jaedyn (from Patrick, Bradley).
Rock [Spadaro, Shay] Service error. 8 Rockhurst 3
CentSt [Trimuel, Prince Michael] Bad set by Jacques, Nathan. 9 Rockhurst 3
CentSt 9 Central St. (OH) 4 [Trimuel, Prince Michael] Service error.
Rock [Yusk, Wesley] Attack error by Tran, Lucas (from Jacques, Nathan). 10 Rockhurst 4
CentSt 10 Central St. (OH) 5 [Smith, Preston] Kill by Huhman, Quentin (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock 10 Central St. (OH) 6 [Huhman, Quentin] Attack error by Williams IV, Toulmin (block by DeRoy, Aron; Tran, Lucas; Jacques, Nathan).
Rock 10 Central St. (OH) 7 [Huhman, Quentin] Attack error by Smith, Preston (from Patrick, Bradley).
Rock 10 Central St. (OH) 8 [Huhman, Quentin] Attack error by Smith, Preston (from Patrick, Bradley).
Rock 10 Central St. (OH) 9 [Huhman, Quentin] Attack error by Falayi, Simon (block by DeRoy, Aron).
Rock [Huhman, Quentin] Attack error by Spadaro, Shay (from Jacques, Nathan). 11 Rockhurst 9
CentSt 11 Central St. (OH) 10 [Williams IV, Toulmin] Attack error by Falayi, Simon.
Rock 11 Central St. (OH) 11 [Tran, Lucas] Service ace (Smith, Preston).
Rock 11 Central St. (OH) 12 [Tran, Lucas] Attack error by Patrick, Bradley (block by DeRoy, Aron).
Rock [Tran, Lucas] Service error. 12 Rockhurst 12
CentSt 12 Central St. (OH) 13 [Falayi, Simon] Service error.
Rock 12 Central St. (OH) 14 [DeRoy, Aron] Attack error by Harris, Jaedyn (block by Yusk, Wesley; Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [DeRoy, Aron] Kill by Harris, Jaedyn (from Patrick, Bradley). 13 Rockhurst 14
CentSt [Patrick, Bradley] Kill by Harris, Jaedyn (from Patrick, Bradley). 14 Rockhurst 14
CentSt 14 Central St. (OH) 15 [Patrick, Bradley] Kill by Yusk, Wesley (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock 14 Central St. (OH) 16 [Jacques, Nathan] Kill by Spadaro, Shay (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [Jacques, Nathan] Kill by Harris, Jaedyn (from Patrick, Bradley). 15 Rockhurst 16
CentSt [Harris, Jaedyn] Service ace (Collins, Ryan). 16 Rockhurst 16
CentSt 16 Central St. (OH) 17 [Harris, Jaedyn] Service error.
Rock 16 Central St. (OH) 18 [Spadaro, Shay] Kill by Yusk, Wesley (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [Spadaro, Shay] Service error. 17 Rockhurst 18
CentSt 17 Central St. (OH) 19 [Trimuel, Prince Michael] Service error.
Rock 17 Central St. (OH) 20 [Yusk, Wesley] Attack error by Williams IV, Toulmin (from Patrick, Bradley).
Rock [Yusk, Wesley] Kill by Smith, Preston (from Patrick, Bradley). 18 Rockhurst 20
CentSt 18 Central St. (OH) 21 [Smith, Preston] Kill by Tran, Lucas (from Spadaro, Shay).
Rock 18 Central St. (OH) 22 [Huhman, Quentin] Service ace (Team).
Rock [Huhman, Quentin] Service error. 19 Rockhurst 22
CentSt 19 Central St. (OH) 23 [Williams IV, Toulmin] Kill by Tran, Lucas (from DeRoy, Aron).
Rock [Tran, Lucas] Kill by Harris, Jaedyn (from Patrick, Bradley). 20 Rockhurst 23
CentSt 20 Central St. (OH) 24 [Falayi, Simon] Service error.
Rock 20 Central St. (OH) 25 [DeRoy, Aron] Attack error by Harris, Jaedyn (from Latham, Benjamin).

Set #2 Plays

Set #2 Plays
Serve Team CentSt - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score Rock - Play Description
CentSt 0 Central St. (OH) 1 [Patrick, Bradley] Kill by Yusk, Wesley (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock 0 Central St. (OH) 2 [Jacques, Nathan] Attack error by Smith, Preston (from Patrick, Bradley).
Rock [Jacques, Nathan] Kill by Smith, Preston (from Patrick, Bradley). 1 Rockhurst 2
CentSt 1 Central St. (OH) 3 [Harris, Jaedyn] Service error.
Rock [Spadaro, Shay] Kill by Williams IV, Toulmin (from Patrick, Bradley). 2 Rockhurst 3
CentSt 2 Central St. (OH) 4 [Trimuel, Prince Michael] Service error.
Rock [Yusk, Wesley] Kill by Smith, Preston (from Patrick, Bradley). 3 Rockhurst 4
CentSt 3 Central St. (OH) 5 [Smith, Preston] Kill by DeRoy, Aron (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [Huhman, Quentin] Kill by Williams IV, Toulmin (from Latham, Benjamin). 4 Rockhurst 5
CentSt 4 Central St. (OH) 6 [Williams IV, Toulmin] Kill by Huhman, Quentin (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [Tran, Lucas] Service error. 5 Rockhurst 6
CentSt 5 Central St. (OH) 7 [Falayi, Simon] Kill by DeRoy, Aron (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [DeRoy, Aron] Service error. 6 Rockhurst 7
CentSt 6 Central St. (OH) 8 [Patrick, Bradley] Service error.
Rock [Jacques, Nathan] Service error. 7 Rockhurst 8
CentSt 7 Central St. (OH) 9 [Harris, Jaedyn] Kill by Spadaro, Shay (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock 7 Central St. (OH) 10 [Spadaro, Shay] Attack error by Smith, Preston (from Patrick, Bradley).
Rock [Spadaro, Shay] Kill by Trimuel, Prince Michael (from Patrick, Bradley). 8 Rockhurst 10
CentSt 8 Central St. (OH) 11 [Trimuel, Prince Michael] Bad set by Patrick, Bradley.
Rock 8 Central St. (OH) 12 [Yusk, Wesley] Attack error by Williams IV, Toulmin (block by DeRoy, Aron; Huhman, Quentin).
Rock 8 Central St. (OH) 13 [Yusk, Wesley] Kill by Huhman, Quentin (from Spadaro, Shay).
Rock 8 Central St. (OH) 14 [Yusk, Wesley] Service ace (Team).
Rock [Yusk, Wesley] Kill by Falayi, Simon (from Patrick, Bradley). 9 Rockhurst 14
CentSt 9 Central St. (OH) 15 [Smith, Preston] Service error.
Rock [Huhman, Quentin] Service error. 10 Rockhurst 15
CentSt [Williams IV, Toulmin] Attack error by DeRoy, Aron (from Jacques, Nathan). 11 Rockhurst 15
CentSt 11 Central St. (OH) 16 [Williams IV, Toulmin] Kill by Huhman, Quentin (from Jacques, Nathan).
-- Rock subs: Massey, Trent.
Rock 11 Central St. (OH) 17 [Massey, Trent] Attack error by Falayi, Simon (block by DeRoy, Aron).
Rock [Massey, Trent] Kill by Harris, Jaedyn (from Latham, Benjamin). 12 Rockhurst 17
CentSt 12 Central St. (OH) 18 [Falayi, Simon] Service error.
Rock 12 Central St. (OH) 19 [DeRoy, Aron] Kill by Spadaro, Shay (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock 12 Central St. (OH) 20 [DeRoy, Aron] Kill by Massey, Trent (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [DeRoy, Aron] Kill by Harris, Jaedyn (from Patrick, Bradley). 13 Rockhurst 20
CentSt 13 Central St. (OH) 21 [Patrick, Bradley] Service error.
Rock [Jacques, Nathan] Attack error by Spadaro, Shay (block by Trimuel, Prince Michael). 14 Rockhurst 21
CentSt 14 Central St. (OH) 22 [Harris, Jaedyn] Service error.
Rock [Spadaro, Shay] Service error. 15 Rockhurst 22
CentSt 15 Central St. (OH) 23 [Trimuel, Prince Michael] Kill by Massey, Trent (from Jacques, Nathan).
-- Rock subs: Soto, Enrique.
Rock [Soto, Enrique] Service error. 16 Rockhurst 23
CentSt 16 Central St. (OH) 24 [Smith, Preston] Attack error by Harris, Jaedyn (from Smith, Preston).
Rock [Huhman, Quentin] Attack error by Spadaro, Shay (from Jacques, Nathan). 17 Rockhurst 24
CentSt [Williams IV, Toulmin] Attack error by Massey, Trent (from Jacques, Nathan). 18 Rockhurst 24
CentSt 18 Central St. (OH) 25 [Williams IV, Toulmin] Kill by Massey, Trent (from Jacques, Nathan).

Set #3 Plays

Set #3 Plays
Serve Team CentSt - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score Rock - Play Description
-- Rock subs: Soto, Enrique; Yusk, Wesley; Collins, Ryan; Tran, Lucas; Sutphen, Will.
-- Rock subs: Daugherty, Jackson.
Rock 0 Central St. (OH) 1 [DeRoy, Aron] Service ace (Williams IV, Toulmin).
Rock [DeRoy, Aron] Kill by Harris, Jaedyn (from Patrick, Bradley). 1 Rockhurst 1
CentSt 1 Central St. (OH) 2 [Patrick, Bradley] Kill by Sutphen, Will (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [Jacques, Nathan] Attack error by Spadaro, Shay (from Daugherty, Jackson). 2 Rockhurst 2
-- Rock subs: Daugherty, Jackson.
CentSt 2 Central St. (OH) 3 [Harris, Jaedyn] Kill by Huhman, Quentin (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [Spadaro, Shay] Service error. 3 Rockhurst 3
CentSt 3 Central St. (OH) 4 [Falayi, Simon] Kill by Huhman, Quentin (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [Sutphen, Will] Kill by Williams IV, Toulmin (from Patrick, Bradley). 4 Rockhurst 4
CentSt [Smith, Preston] Kill by Williams IV, Toulmin (from Latham, Benjamin). 5 Rockhurst 4
CentSt 5 Central St. (OH) 5 [Smith, Preston] Kill by DeRoy, Aron (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock 5 Central St. (OH) 6 [Huhman, Quentin] Kill by Huhman, Quentin (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock 5 Central St. (OH) 7 [Huhman, Quentin] Kill by Spadaro, Shay.
Rock 5 Central St. (OH) 8 [Huhman, Quentin] Kill by Massey, Trent.
Rock [Huhman, Quentin] Kill by Williams IV, Toulmin (from Patrick, Bradley). 6 Rockhurst 8
CentSt [Williams IV, Toulmin] Attack error by Huhman, Quentin (from Jacques, Nathan). 7 Rockhurst 8
CentSt 7 Central St. (OH) 9 [Williams IV, Toulmin] Bad set by Patrick, Bradley.
Rock 7 Central St. (OH) 10 [Massey, Trent] Attack error by Trimuel, Prince Michael (from Patrick, Bradley).
Rock [Massey, Trent] Kill by Trimuel, Prince Michael (from Patrick, Bradley). 8 Rockhurst 10
CentSt [Trimuel, Prince Michael] Attack error by Spadaro, Shay (block by Patrick, Bradley). 9 Rockhurst 10
CentSt 9 Central St. (OH) 11 [Trimuel, Prince Michael] Kill by Jacques, Nathan (from DeRoy, Aron).
Rock [DeRoy, Aron] Kill by Falayi, Simon (from Patrick, Bradley). 10 Rockhurst 11
CentSt 10 Central St. (OH) 12 [Patrick, Bradley] Attack error by Harris, Jaedyn (from Patrick, Bradley).
Rock [Jacques, Nathan] Attack error by Huhman, Quentin (block by Falayi, Simon; Smith, Preston). 11 Rockhurst 12
-- CentSt subs: Symes, Deegan.
CentSt [Symes, Deegan] Kill by Williams IV, Toulmin (from Patrick, Bradley). 12 Rockhurst 12
CentSt 12 Central St. (OH) 13 [Symes, Deegan] Service error.
Rock [Spadaro, Shay] Kill by Falayi, Simon (from Patrick, Bradley). 13 Rockhurst 13
CentSt 13 Central St. (OH) 14 [Falayi, Simon] Kill by Huhman, Quentin (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock 13 Central St. (OH) 15 [Sutphen, Will] Attack error by Williams IV, Toulmin (from Symes, Deegan).
Rock 13 Central St. (OH) 16 [Sutphen, Will] Kill by Huhman, Quentin (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [Sutphen, Will] Kill by Trimuel, Prince Michael (from Patrick, Bradley). 14 Rockhurst 16
CentSt 14 Central St. (OH) 17 [Smith, Preston] Kill by Huhman, Quentin (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [Huhman, Quentin] Kill by Williams IV, Toulmin (from Patrick, Bradley). 15 Rockhurst 17
CentSt 15 Central St. (OH) 18 [Williams IV, Toulmin] Kill by Massey, Trent (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock 15 Central St. (OH) 19 [Massey, Trent] Kill by Spadaro, Shay (from Huhman, Quentin).
Rock 15 Central St. (OH) 20 [Massey, Trent] Attack error by Symes, Deegan (from Patrick, Bradley).
Rock [Massey, Trent] Kill by Trimuel, Prince Michael (from Patrick, Bradley). 16 Rockhurst 20
CentSt [Trimuel, Prince Michael] Attack error by Spadaro, Shay (block by Patrick, Bradley; Falayi, Simon). 17 Rockhurst 20
CentSt [Trimuel, Prince Michael] Attack error by Jacques, Nathan (block by Symes, Deegan; Falayi, Simon). 18 Rockhurst 20
CentSt [Trimuel, Prince Michael] Kill by Falayi, Simon (from Patrick, Bradley). 19 Rockhurst 20
CentSt 19 Central St. (OH) 21 [Trimuel, Prince Michael] Kill by Spadaro, Shay (from Jacques, Nathan).
-- Rock subs: McCue, Bailey.
Rock [McCue, Bailey] Kill by Symes, Deegan (from Patrick, Bradley). 20 Rockhurst 21
CentSt 20 Central St. (OH) 22 [Patrick, Bradley] Kill by Spadaro, Shay (from Jacques, Nathan).
Rock [Jacques, Nathan] Kill by Falayi, Simon (from Patrick, Bradley). 21 Rockhurst 22
CentSt [Symes, Deegan] Kill by Falayi, Simon (from Patrick, Bradley). 22 Rockhurst 22
CentSt 22 Central St. (OH) 23 [Symes, Deegan] Service error.
Rock 22 Central St. (OH) 24 [Spadaro, Shay] Attack error by Falayi, Simon (from Patrick, Bradley).
Rock [Spadaro, Shay] Kill by Falayi, Simon (from Patrick, Bradley). 23 Rockhurst 24
-- CentSt subs: Durrah, Jayden.
CentSt 23 Central St. (OH) 25 [Durrah, Jayden] Attack error by Williams IV, Toulmin (from Spadaro, Shay).